Fall Shoe Review: What to Add to your Collection

Marilyn Monroe was quoted as saying, “Give a girl the right shoes and she can conquer the world.” I couldn’t agree more. However finding the right footwear is no easy feat. (Yes, a play on words, but so very true.) You need to consider the activity or occasion for which you are dressing, as well as the clothing you are wearing. You also need to honor your style preferences, which evolve and change over time. Additionally, there is the push/pull of fashion and function that comes into play. And it doesn’t help matters that we’re spoiled for choice each season.

If you’re confused about what shoe (or boot) to add to your fall footwear collection, trust me. You are not alone. So, let’s keep things simple and approach this from more of an aerial view.

Regardless of your lifestyle or the “it” shoe of the moment, there are six basic shoe categories that make up a well-rounded, cold-weather shoe wardrobe. For a look at what they are – and what role they play in your wardrobe – read on, my “sole-searching” friends.

Flat boots/booties are a perfect choice for active days. Whether you are running errands, taking a class at a nearby college, or working in a casual setting, they’re up to the challenge of your busy life. Choose a style that relates to your personal expression. You may like a Chelsea boot or a riding boot if you are drawn to a classic look. Or perhaps you prefer a boot with western details. If you like variety in your life, you’ll want to have boots or booties in more than one color and style.  Cover your neutral-colored bases first – brown, charcoal gray, tan or black – but don’t be afraid to purchase a pair in a pop of color.

Dressy boots/booties are a must-have for women who enjoy a more glam or formal look. These boots are generally more elegant and heeled. They are perfect for wearing with fabrics like lace, velvet, brocade or jacquard. With these dressy options, consider black (the most formal of hues) or a luxe burgundy, in a smooth calf leather, luxe suede or patent finish. Since this type of boot is generally close-fitting to the ankle and calf, you might opt for one with a panel of stretchy fabric. (Note: if you’ve got fuller calf and shop online, simply add the words “wide calf” to your search.)

Dressy flats are perfect for a more polished outfit or they can up-level your look when worn with casual pieces, like jeans and a sweater. (You may have noticed that fashion bloggers love to pair casual and elegant elements together because it adds more visual interest to a daytime look.) What makes a flat dressier is the details. Look for shoes that are beaded, have sequins, ornate buckles or bows. They could be ballet flats, slipper-type loafers or sling-backs. Think metallic, patent leather, velvet, animal print or lace, and you’re on the right track. In the past few seasons flats have become more fashion-forward, so no need to sacrifice style for comfort.

Oxfords are a popular choice if you prefer a menswear look to your shoes. The fact that they lace up can give you a personalized fit. Lace them tight if your heel or foot is narrow. If your foot is fuller, give the laces some slack. An oxford looks sharp with trousers, ankle pants or rolled up jeans. Shop around and you will discover this style comes in a variety of textures and materials. They may be adorned with tassels, have lug soles or be heeled. Try teaming them with a more feminine clothing item for a fun juxtaposition of yin and yang.

Pumps can function as the professional go-to shoe for many workplaces. Work pumps have a closed-toe and are typically kitten or mid-heeled. They can have a pointy, almond-shaped or rounded front and feature an ankle wrap or sling back. The block-heeled pump is a comfortable and modern addition to any shoe wardrobe. While it’s true that a higher (4” and up) and slender-heeled pump (a.k.a “cab” shoes) can look dressy (and sexy), you may want to save them for evenings or special occasions.

Sneakers offer a modern look and are comfortable to boot! They are having their fashion moment and many of us (including yours truly) could not be happier. These days sneakers range from sporty to chic. You can choose a casual pair that laces up and looks athletic, or opt for snazzy, slip-on sneakers in materials like embossed leather, leopard print, or velvet.  If your mode of dress skews casual or if you spend a good deal of time on your feet, you may want to invest in a few pairs of this comfy, yet stylish shoe style.

You may be wondering how many shoes you should own in each category. The answer depends on your lifestyle. Think about how you spend your time each week (168 hours in total). The more hours you spend on an activity (for example, work), the more shoes you should have for that activity. The less time you spend on an activity (i.e., going to black-tie functions), the fewer shoes you should have for that activity. When you think about your time commitments vs. your current shoe inventory, you are able to assess what category of shoes you need more (or less) of.  You can then build your shoe shopping list from there.

If building – or editing – your fall/winter wardrobe seems like a daunting task, please don’t hesitate to reach out. I would love nothing more than to help you “step” into the season in style~

About Carol Davidson

I’m Carol Davidson — certified image consultant and life coach, speaker, and educator. For almost 25 years, I’ve helped countless clients celebrate their unique qualities, and embody true confidence. From revamping your wardrobe to easing you into a new phase of life, I create a safe, supportive space to help you take on whatever you want to create next.